Your Farm-to-Table Thanksgiving Starts Here!

This Thanksgiving, curate an unforgettable feast that celebrates local roots and community essence.

Savor the difference with your pasture-raised turkey, the centerpiece of your table, surrounded by an array of succulent sides and divine pies, all bursting with flavor.

Discover the freshness our local vendors have to offer to make your holiday truly unique.

Explore our vendors and their tantalizing offerings below...

And remember, if you haven't secured your turkey yet, now's the time to order and ensure a Thanksgiving feast that's nothing short of extraordinary!

Thanksgiving Farmers’ Market

Saturday, November 23, 2024

11am-1pm • Rain, Shine, or Snow

Note, the start time.

Outdoors behind The Narrowsburg Union, 7 Erie Avenue, Narrowsburg, NY.

Thanksgiving Eats, Drinks & Treats

Aaron Burr Cider

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • 2020 Sullivan County Magnum (1500ml, 7.5% abv) Wild Apple Cider from over 300+ wild apples foraged in the Sullivan Catskills — the perfect local beverage to serve with your Thanksgiving meal! $40

    Pre-Order

  • Health!

    Andy overcame a health crisis and is now out picking apples!

  • Roasted Brussels sprouts! So delicious and healthy.

Beach Lake Bakery

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Assorted breads and rolls.

  • We’re grateful for the people who bring joy, comfort, and support into our lives.

  • Pie!

Cakes & Scones Bakery

Facebook

  • Pies

    • Triple Apple Crumb $20

    • Double Crust Apple $20

    • Bourbon Pecan $20

    • Coconut Custard $15

    • Cherry Apple with Almond Crumb $20

    • Chocolate Cream $20

    • Pumpkin with Walnut Ginger Streusel $20

    Specialty Items

    • 6” Pumpkin Bundt Cake with Caramel Glaze $14

    • 9” Single Layer Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting $25

    • 9” Peanut Butter Mousse Tart $28

    • 9×9 Peach Cobbler $20

    Savory Items

    • Corn Pudding $18

    • Chourico & Cornbread Stuffing $18

    • Cranberry Relish (16oz.) $6

    Deadline to Order for Market Pick-Up

    • Saturday, November 16

    Pre-Order

    • Call 570-676–4155

  • I’m most grateful for having the resolve to change my my life and being rewarded with  happiness, peace, supportive relationships and self love.

  • My favorite Thanksgiving dishes are Choirico Stuffing and Corn Pudding. I love it all!

Four Story Hill Farm

570.224.4137 | Email

  • Fresh Farm-Raised Turkey

    • Turkeys are 16lbs+ / $7.95 per pound

    • Market Pick Up: Saturday, November 23

    • Farm Pick Up: Monday, November 18, Tuesday, November 19, Monday, November 25 or Tuesday, November 26.

    Fresh Farm Raised Capons

    • Capons are 8lbs+ / $9.25 per pound

    • Same pick-up dates as the Turkeys.

    Beef Ribeye Roast (boneless)

    • 2.5 to 3.5lbs / $32.95 per pound

    • Must be pre-ordered by Sunday, November 10 for Market pick-up on 11/23.

    • Non-refundable deposit due when you order.

    Deadline to Order

    • Friday, November 15

    It is advisable and encouraged to reserve your order sooner rather than later to secure the size and quantity preferred.

  • I am thankful for so many things…

    My family and the lovely customers and vendors at the Narrowsburg Farmers’ Market.

    And I’m grateful for our market managers — Danielle and Jennifer — for caring so much and treating us with their delicious cooking and baking!

  • Sausage stuffing!

Soraia’s Kitchen

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Stock up on Quiche, Soup, Chili, Sauces, Empanadas, Jam, and Gluten Free Baked Goods — all freezer friendly, perfect for on-the-go eating.

    Thanksgiving Appetizer Box

    • Spinach Cheese Puffs

    • Stuffed Jalapeño Poppers

    • Crab Cakes with Mustard Sauce

    • Baked Cream Cheese & Chicken Wontons

    Breads & Baked Goods

    • Cranberry-Walnut Rye Bread

    • Cranberry Walnut Loafs

    • Scones

    • Biscuits

    • Cookies

    • Focaccia

  • I’m grateful to live and work in a vibrant, progressive community that supports small businesses.

  • A great stuffing!

Sprouting Dreams Farm

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Microgreens, winter squash, potatoes, onions, and more!

  • All the challenges which inevitably became opportunities to grow.

  • Mashed potatoes with a mushroom gravy and dark turkey meat.

Two Creek Farm

Beach Lake Bakery sold here.

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Stock up on grass fed and finished beef, forested organic pork, pastured organic chicken and turkey, organic rainbow eggs, raw honey, tallow and lard soap.

    You’ll also find Beach Lake Bakery bread.

    Turkeys available for pre-order — click here.

  • As our busy and successful production season winds down, we are grateful to recharge and reconnect with friends and family.

  • A Two Creek organic turkey for sure — what else?!?

Willow Wisp Organic Farm

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Salad Greens, Kales, Radicchios, Spinach, Carrots, Cabbage, Potatoes, Sunchokes, Garlic, Radishes, Herbs.

  • I am grateful for customers who understand the value of our food.

    Their purchases support my family, my team, and good farming practices.

  • My favorite Thanksgiving dish is Roasted Sunchokes with Garlic!

Yemallah Naturals

Website | Facebook | Instagram

  • Thoughtful gifts for your Thanksgiving host — all-natural healing products, handmade jewelry, ceramics, and more.

  • I am profoundly grateful for the unwavering support I’ve received from my family and community, which has been essential to the growth and success of our Indigenous wellness company, Yemallah Naturals and farm, Moor Acres Farm.

    Their encouragement and trust in our mission has inspired me every step of the way.

    My family has been my unwavering foundation, dedicating their time and love to help bring our vision to life.

    Together, we’ve cultivated not only herbs but also a shared commitment to healing and wellness that reflects our rich heritage.

    The support from our community has been invaluable, from the countless hands that have helped in the fields to the voices that spread the word about our mission, products, and offerings.

    Their trust in the power of natural healing and Indigenous knowledge has transformed our journey into a collective celebration of culture and healing.

    I am incredibly thankful for this journey we share, and I look forward to continuing to grow together, nurturing both our land and our community for generations to come. 

    With Peace, Love, and Gratitude,

    Nu - Yemallah Naturals

  • While we don’t traditionally “celebrate” Thanksgiving as Indigenous people, my favorite dish during the Harvest season is cornbread dressing.

    This savory delight is made with caramelized onions, fresh vegetables, and, of course, cornbread — all infused with love.

    It’s a recipe passed down from my foremothers, and each year, I look forward to preparing it for my family and friends.

    It’s a beautiful way to honor our heritage and share a meaningful meal together.

 

Thanksgiving Turkey Recipe

Serves 8 to 10 people

The recipe comes from a former Chef at Per Se Restaurant in NYC, who has been sourcing from Four Story Hill Farm for the past 10 years.


 

Ingredients

  • 12-14 pound farm-fresh turkey

  • 2 lemons

  • 1 orange

  • 1⁄2 cup unsalted butter, softened

  • 2 tablespoons chopped fresh sage

  • 2 tablespoons fresh thyme leaves

  • 4 cloves garlic, minced

  • 1 tablespoon kosher salt

  • 2 teaspoons black pepper 

  • 2 cups dry white wine

  • 2 cups chicken stock, low-sodium

  • 4 sprigs sage

  • 8 sprigs thyme 

Method 

  1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Dry turkey with a paper towel and remove giblets. Place it on a rack in a roasting pan.

  2. Zest orange and lemons.

  3. In a small bowl, combine the butter with the zests, sage, thyme, garlic, salt, and pepper. Gently place under the skin of the breast. Put the skin back down and season the skin liberally with kosher salt and pepper. 

  4. Tuck the turkey's wings under the bird and tie its legs together with twine. Pour the wine and chicken stock into the roasting pan. Tie sprigs of sage and thyme together with twine and place them in the liquid.

  5. Cook until 160 degrees — when resting, the turkey will reach the safe temperature of 165. Start checking the temperature after two hours of cooking. Baste the bird with the liquid every 30 minutes. Cover it with foil if it gets too dark. 

  6. Allow to rest for 30 minutes. Carve and enjoy!